MTG PRINTING GUIDE
Living Death’s original is a nonfoil Tempest rare by Charles Gillespie. Later printings provide Mark Winters’ artwork in ordinary finishes and L J Koh’s Warhammer interpretation in separate nonfoil and surge-foil records. The card’s dramatic reputation comes from a precise, symmetrical sequence of graveyard exile, sacrifice and return; choosing a premium edition does not change which creatures actually come back.
QUICK ANSWER
Living Death first appeared in Tempest (TMP), 14 October 1997. The original is TMP #142, at rare, illustrated by Charles Gillespie. Available original finishes: Nonfoil only.
Printing records and official context reviewed . Use the shortlist for a physical-edition comparison and the explorer for current availability and format data.
Artwork could not load. The exact printing and source links remain available.
REPRESENTATIVE PRINTING
This static reference remains readable while live data loads. The interactive selected printing replaces it once verified data is available.
Check this exact catalogue record · View this printing on Scryfall
Live printing data loads separately.
RULES & FORMAT CONTEXT
Living Death costs {3}{B}{B}. First each player exiles all creature cards from their graveyard; then each sacrifices all creatures they control; finally the cards exiled by the first instruction return to the battlefield. It is a symmetrical effect, not a one-sided reanimation spell.
Creatures sacrificed during the second instruction are not among the cards exiled by the first, so they do not immediately return through this spell. Indestructible does not prevent sacrifice. Players do not receive priority between these instructions while the spell resolves.
That sequence rewards graveyard preparation and makes opponents’ graveyards relevant. Worldly Tutor finds a creature for the library’s top rather than the graveyard; Skullclamp turns appropriate creature deaths into draw. They support different resource exchanges, not interchangeable forms of reanimation.
PRINTING HISTORY
Tempest #142, released on 14 October 1997, is the debut: rare, Charles Gillespie, nonfoil only. A foil with a later edition code should not be advertised as an original Tempest booster foil.
Masters 25 #96 arrived in March 2018 with Mark Winters’ illustration and both nonfoil and traditional foil. It is a useful modern reference for that art, rather than a claim to be the first ever foil or the first appearance of the painting.
Warhammer 40,000 Commander introduced L J Koh’s illustration in October 2022. The ordinary deck record is #202 and nonfoil-only; the Collector’s Edition record is #202★ and surge-foil-only. The star matters when identifying the physical version.
Tarkir: Dragonstorm Commander #185 followed in April 2025, returning to Winters’ art in a nonfoil-only record. These are selected physical comparisons, not a complete chronology of every boxed or Commander reprint. Vintage Masters belongs to Magic Online and is not an additional paper edition.
PRINTING SHORTLIST
Selected physical editions; not every language, digital entry or minor reprint.
| Release / set | Collector number | Rarity | Artwork / treatment | Artist | Available finishes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tempest (1997) | TMP #142 | rare | Original illustration | Charles Gillespie | Nonfoil only |
| Masters 25 (2018) | A25 #96 | rare | Alternate illustration | Mark Winters | Nonfoil, traditional foil |
| Warhammer 40,000 Commander (2022) | 40K #202 | rare | Warhammer alternate illustration | L J Koh | Nonfoil only |
| Warhammer 40,000 Commander (2022) | 40K #202★ | rare | Collector’s Edition; separate starred record | L J Koh | Surge foil only |
| Tarkir: Dragonstorm Commander (2025) | TDC #185 | rare | Later Commander deck reprint | Mark Winters | Nonfoil only |
Finish labels belong to the individual source record. An etched or textured treatment is not an extra finish invented for every edition. A missing price is unknown, not zero.
ARTWORK & FRAME COMPARISON
Gillespie’s Tempest illustration is the historical anchor. Winters and Koh provide two later credited interpretations, so those are genuine artwork changes rather than just new expansion symbols around the original.
A25 #96 and TDC #185 let you compare later products with Winters’ artwork. Keep their finish menus separate: Masters 25 supports traditional foil, while the listed Tarkir deck record does not.
The Warhammer pair holds Koh’s artwork broadly constant while changing physical finish and catalogue identity. This is a useful controlled comparison if you like the illustration but are deciding between ordinary deck and Collector’s Edition surfaces.
FOILS & SPECIAL TREATMENTS
The original TMP #142 is nonfoil-only. For a traditional foil of the Winters artwork, A25 #96 is one verified option. It is not an etched or textured edition simply because it is a Masters printing.
For surge foil, identify 40K #202★ explicitly. Do not apply that finish to #202 or assume that every Warhammer product card can be switched between nonfoil and surge without changing its exact record. Inspect physical photographs when comparing the moving reflective pattern.
MANASCOUT RECOMMENDATIONS
Original-edition collection: TMP #142 nonfoil preserves the Tempest debut and Gillespie credit. Confirm the set rather than relying on an old-looking frame.
Modern art with a finish choice: A25 #96 offers Winters’ illustration in nonfoil or traditional foil. TDC #185 is a later nonfoil comparison with that artist.
Setting-led deck: Koh’s Warhammer image offers a distinct visual identity. Choose #202 for nonfoil or #202★ for the verified surge surface.
Deck construction: choose the actual card for its symmetrical rules before curating its edition in Deck Studio. Individual and bulk printing choices preserve gameplay identity; they do not repair an unsuitable graveyard plan.
ALL PRINTINGS / LIVE EXPLORER
Use the shared set, language and finish filters to inspect an exact printing. Cardmarket links are independent third-party destinations. Catalogue prices are live reference fields where available, not fixed GBP offers. The digital foil animation is illustrative, not a photograph of a physical finish.
SCOUT MORE
Skullclamp — compare the related card’s own printing history and collector choices.
Worldly Tutor — compare the related card’s own printing history and collector choices.
Demonic Tutor — compare the related card’s own printing history and collector choices.
Edgar Markov — compare the related card’s own printing history and collector choices.
SOURCES & EDITORIAL REVIEW
Reviewed . The linked exact-edition catalogue records support dates, artists, rarity and finish availability; official sources support product treatment and format context where cited. The live explorer retrieves current Scryfall data separately. This is a dated editorial selection, not a guarantee of stock, price or unchanged future legality.